Monday, March 16, 2009

Frank, Obama "Galt" AIG UPDATED

Barney Frank (D-MA) and Barack Obama have condemned AIG's plans for $165 million in bonuses. Assuming those bonuses are going to "over paid" executives making $250k or more, that $165 million would've netted the IRS a tidy $57 million in income tax.

Unemployment seems to be up. Let's hire $165 million worth of $30k/yr employees and see how the tax revenue works out! Here are the numbers:
  • $30,000 annual salary
  • $2,295 employee FICA contribution
  • $2,295 employer FICA contribution
  • $500/mo health plan ($6000/yr)
  • $5,450 standard deduction
  • $3,282 income tax
  • $38,295 per employee cost
  • $7,872 per employee federal tax
The per employee cost implies that we can hire about 4,300 people. This cohort will garner the government about $34 million in revenue. The loss in government revenue may only be $23 million, but it's much worse than that. Since about %60 of the $34 million is to FICA, our cohort has created a significant future obligation for the US government.

Perhaps that $165 million will be spent in a way that will garner more taxes, but that does not seem likely. In effect, Barney Frank and Barack Obama have "galted" the AIG bonuses by reducing the government revenue on that money. Who knew we would have friends in such high places!?!

Personally, I have mixed feelings about the AIG bonuses. Megan McArdle captures my sentiments well: "...the AIG retention bonuses raise a question the government is going to have to ask again and again before all this is over: do we want to make a point, or do we want to make money?"

I think the economic crisis and ensuing turmoil will reveal that our "progressive" tax system is quite brittle. Tax revenues are going down and our politicians will continue to raise taxes on the top quintile. That will cause some employees to increase their compensation by asking for more vacation time or a four day work week while maintaining or decreasing their salary. Given the high unemployment, many people will choose to be underemployed. This will also reduce government tax revenues.

Note: In my example, I'm ignoring the earned income tax credit. I assume all employees are single. If we hire married people, both the health plan and the standard deduction go up, reducing the per employee tax burden.

Update 4/2/2009: I didn't realize this because it has not been widely reported, but many (most?) of the AIG employees receiving these bonuses, have opted to take a 1$/yr salary (Don Surber noticed). I heard this from a banking friend. Bill Whittle alludes to it in his Tone Deaf 2 post. Obviously, that changes all the math above.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Will the People Leave?

I recently added Clay Shirky's blog to my blogroll (for his essays, go here). I've always found his writing thought provoking. His recent post left me with a couple of questions, so here's what I just emailed him (with a few edits):
I love your work, just love it. About your newspaper blog post… here are some follow-on questions to think about:
  1. When will the problems with newspapers trickle-up to broadcasting? (Broadcast doesn’t have the craigslist problem, but I still think they’re vulnerable.)
  2. Why do we still have libraries? When will they mostly disappear? When will they be replaced with a server hosting a copy of the Gutenberg project and/or Wikipedia?
  3. If small classes sizes are so great, why not require homeschooling?
  4. When will it be possible to get a masters degree by attending iTunes University? A PhD? Why pay for the sheepskin?
Here’s a much deeper question… In “Ontology is Overrated” you said: “…East Germany actually turned out to be an unstable category. Cities are real. They are real, physical facts. Countries are social fictions.” It’s been years since I read that article—I still recommend it to friends, though. Anyway, I’ve been wondering if cities might become “less real” during/after the tumult you discussed in your newspaper blog post. 5. What is the value proposition of "the city"? I live in St Louis, MO. I get to pay 1% annual income tax to the city. The schools are unaccredited. Crime is high.

To be a little dark… What happens if a city somewhere in the world is nuked? City property values the world over will go down while non-city property values will go up. What about a second nuke and so on? I certainly hope none of that happens. Nonetheless, I think humanity’s future will more closely resemble peer-to-peer networks than the current client-server architecture sustaining our cities.
Leave your thoughts in the comments!

Update: Will more cities look like Detroit?

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Washington Should Continue to Favor Long-Buyers

Instapundit links to Rich Karlgaard's Washington Should Stop Favoring Short-Sellers. (Before we get started, do not take my investment advice. While misery may love company, you certainly do not want to be that miserable ;-) Rich omits several details about shorting equities, so I'm mostly faulting him for errors of omission. Perhaps he just didn't know—it's been known to happen (see below). Rich writes:
For investors, the question is: Does it still work to bet against the popular mood? I think so, but the worm in this apple is bad public policy. Specifically, the cockeyed policy that has, since late 2007, tilted the investing playing field toward short selling. Good public policy should not side with either longs or shorts. Policy should be neutral.
I do not feel that the playing field is tilted toward short selling. Nor do I see how anyone could honestly claim that it was. More importantly, the current regulatory scheme favoring long positions is better than a neutral policy.

There are several policies tilting the market long. First, you cannot establish a short position in an IRA account. Second, you cannot short mutual funds. It's possible that part of the assets of a mutual fund could be used for short positions. However, the regulatory requirements make this unlikely. The regulations described here explain why:
The Investment Company Act severely restricts a mutual fund's ability to leverage or borrow against the value of securities in its portfolio. The SEC requires that funds engaging in certain investment techniques, including the use of options, futures, forward contracts and short selling, "cover" their positions. The effect of these constraints has been to strictly limit leveraging by mutual fund portfolio managers.
In other words, the people least leveraged in the recent economic implosion (elderly folks with IRAs bulging with mutual funds) were some of the hardest hit. Did I mention that mutual funds only trade at the end of the day? The price of a mutual fund is set when the market closes. This means that on days where the market loses 5% of its value, you cannot cash-out your mutual fund to avoid further loses. You certainly can't flip a mutual fund in your IRA to a short position in the hopes of recouping some of what you losed. For these reasons, I prefer ETFs to mutual funds.

Back to the long tilt of market policy... Third, short sales can only be "day" orders. This rule was imposed in the wake of last year's meltdown. When placing a buy or sell limit order, you have to specify the duration of the order. The duration may be just for today (a day order) or good-til-cancel (GTC) which can be several months out. (Ok, there are a few others, but that would expose minutea that even I do not care about.) If you want to establish a short position in QQQQ (full disclosure: I'm currently short QQQQ) you have to place the order after the previous day's market close. You cannot simply enter that order on Sunday and review it the next weekend. This means that there's slightly more work involved in shorting (you have to enter your shorts daily).

Fourth, short interest is reported monthly and, if it's too high, there could be a short sqeeze. The short interest for QQQQ (153,801,007) is near the daily trading volume (173,147,912). That means that the days to cover is about 1. Combined with the good liquidity (high trading volumes), I believe the risk of a short squeeze is pretty low. Nonetheless, a squeeze would acrue to the benefit of the longs.

Lastly, if an equity you shorted pays a dividend, then you pay that dividend. If more companies paid regular dividends, there would be less short interest.

Karlgaard has three recommendations:
1. Suspend mark-to-market accounting
2. Make the SEC enforce its own ban against naked shorting.
3. Reinstate the short-uptick rule.
I don't think #1 is relevant to his argument. It would cause the firesale of a few banking concerns as companies would have to realize their paper loses. And, "suspending" it is a really bad idea. This market needs certainty and "suspend" is a word littered with temporal ambiguity. I'm not even convinced that mark-to-market is a bad thing.

Rich is spot on with #2. I don't know how the SEC can do this, but I agree.

I also agree with #3. In fact, I didn't know that rule had been remove—it's been known to happen ;-)

I will pick one last nit: Rich, if you want a "neutral policy" and the "short-uptick rule", would you also advocate a long-downtick rule? I would say no, because the market is not a zero-sum game. The policy should be appropriately biased towards longs.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

wow... That's A LOT of John Galts

Via Instapundit, we learn that self-employment is the main source of job creation in NYC. Glenn links to a Newsalert article that says in part:
...of the 773,000 jobs that Gotham added from 1981 to 2006, a stunning 491,000 were people working for themselves, making self-employment the biggest source of job creation in the city.
Has DC awakened a slumbering giant?

A Walk with the Girls

Last Friday I took the girls out for a walk in the neighborhood. The weather was great—more summer than spring. The four year old was riding her big-wheel while I carried her little sister.

As we passed one house an older gentleman called out to us. He was excited to see the little ones and proud to list off his children, grand-children, and great-grand-children. He told me about his time in WWII. At 84 he's seen a lot, including Europe from the vantage point of a ball turret on a B-24. His first mission was on June 6, 1944, D-Day.

The four year old had peddled off and was nearly at the next corner, so I had to excuse myself. I told him we would be walking around the neighborhood a lot in the coming months. There would be other times to stop and chat.

On Saturday, I saw another story about a B-24 ball turret gunner: Sippican Cottage: My Father Asks For Nothing. I've printed out a copy to deliver to the one I know.

Monday, March 9, 2009

Walk on the Fed?


Alex Tabarrok of MarginalRevolution notes that safe's are a counter-cyclical asset. Last week I heard a radio advertisement that, in part, went: "whether you need a gun safe for your home or a vault for your business..." Alex includes a graph of the currency component of the money supply. I've included the same here using a slightly different dataset. FWIW, currency has gone from $760B at the beginning of the recession to about $840B. That's about a 10.5% increase in currency, so I think it's more a bank "walk" than a bank run.

How did this happen? I suspect there are a lot of people who have decided to get another $10 back at the grocery store when they pay with a debit card. Others are getting another $20 each time they visit an ATM.

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Our Leader

I just saw that picture headlined on Drudge. It's nice to see a picture of our leader, XD-235, but I don't understand why the focus is on XD's voice talent. You'd think the leader of the free world would get more respect!

Thursday, March 5, 2009

Unsupervised!?!

Don Boudreaux quotes a letter by Daniel Gallington. In part Daniel says: "...the economic power of the private sector, especially if unsupervised..."

Unsupervised!?! Are you kidding me? Here's a list of "supervisors" that failed to prevent various and sundry aspects of the financial meltdown:
  1. Congress (House and Senate, added 3/7/9)
  2. US Treasury
  3. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC)
  4. Federal Reserve ("The Fed")
  5. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC)
  6. Security and Exchange Commission (SEC)
  7. Bureau of the Public Debt (I bet they're busy these days!)
  8. Community Development Financial Institution Fund (CDFI)
  9. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN)
  10. Federal Inspectors General
  11. Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS)
  12. National Credit Union Administration (NCUA)
  13. Housing and Urban Development (HUD)
  14. Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity (FHEO)
  15. Federal Housing Administration (FHA)
  16. Fannie Mae
  17. Freddie Mac
  18. Ginnie Mae
Oh, yeah. Yeah. No one was watching the hen house, Danny! Truth is, none of them did a very good job and some of them had conflicts of interest—Freddie and Fannie both gave generously to Obama.

Let's review the second rule of bureaucracy. Rule 1, of course, is: Spend Your Budget. Rule 2 is: Fail. "Why fail," you may ask, because once you've failed you can ask for more money and more power. Failure is how you grow your bureaucratic fiefdom. With failure you get a larger budget next year. If you were to succeed, then someone might want to "improve your efficiency" by reducing your budget.

Update: Director Blue's Meltdown post reminded me of the most important supervisor: Congress. I've added them to the top of my list. Go back to those rules of bureaucracy and pay particular attention to Rule 3: Cover Your Ass.

Mankiw on Fiscal Multipliers

Greg Mankiw highlights the debate about whether fiscal stimulus multipliers are large or small.
He's explained elsewhere that marginal propensity to consume (MPC) increases (in contrast to average propensity to consume) during times of uncertainty. Therefore, he tends to agree with the Obama administration that fiscal multipliers will be "larger than normal as well".

I wonder if his MPC argument applies to dollars themselves. That is, during times of uncertainty, are consumers more likely to spend the spare change or drop it in a jar at home? In light of the Bloomberg report that the FDIC might run out of money this year, I wonder where consumers are putting their marginal dollars. Are they putting them in Bank of America or their mattress?

Update: Congress is considering a loan to the FDIC.

Such an Obvious Target for Civil Disobedience

Pranksters everywhere, take note: Barry needs his teleprompter. If you're looking to have a little fun, you might unplug it. Personally, I'd like to see a well-loved security blanket thrown over it. How about someone in hockey pads checking XD-235 into the boards?

The best part will be when XD gets his own Secret Service detachment. I look forward to seeing pictures of a teleprompter protected by a battalion of Men in Black!